If you miss this, Judy will never forgive you.

Come. Laugh. Oy!


This farce, with book and lyrics by Brian Hargrove and music and concept by Barbara Anselmi, was one big laugh riot from beginning to end. Once again, The Gallery Players has produced another top-notch production that is a must see! – Dr. Philip Ernest Schoenberg, Applause! Applause!


There are many surprises and reveals in It Shoulda Been You, performed to perfection in this hilarious production at The Gallery Players.- Dr. Thomas Robert Stevens, Applause! Applause!


What a delightful production! An excellent performance of a very entertaining, laugh-out-loud musical comedy. I really didn’t expect such a fun, engaging performance; but this Gallery Players production was truly excellent. The cast were all wonderful, and the singing and staging were excellent. Most definitely worth the trip to Park Slope! – Eric 628061

(click for more information)

Fresh from Broadway, comes this farce set to music. One of the funniest musicals of the decade, It Shoulda Been You invites you to the Steinberg wedding, where anything that can go wrong does, and love pops up in mysterious places. It’s a wedding day you’ll never forget!

  • Joseph Peterson, Sam Laakso and Sonya Rice in IT SHOULDA BEEN YOU (photo and Lighting Design by Scott Andrew Cally)

  • Lorinne Lampert in IT SHOULDA BEEN YOU (photo and Lighting Design by Scott Andrew Cally

Here’s what’s coming up in Season 51!


Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat



An unbelievable, record-setting Season 50

Thank you for a successful Season 49!

Celebrating Season 48

For synopses and more information, visit our season page.

Our latest news and opportunities can be found in the sidebar to the right. You may also use the menu bar above. Thanks for visiting!

"Broadway In Brooklyn" Since 1967!

The Gallery Players is Brooklyn's premier Off-Off Broadway theater. Beloved on both sides of the Brooklyn Bridge, this "little theater that could" is located in one of Brooklyn's most popular neighborhoods, Park Slope. Recipient of the Off-Off Broadway Review's 2000 Award for Lifetime Achievement and numerous New York Innovative Theatre Awards, the Gallery Players is dedicated to producing classic and contemporary plays and musicals as well as premiering new works; providing opportunities for acting, directing, design, and musical talent, and quality experiences for audience members at affordable prices. Become a Gallery Players subscriber today!

From the Gallery Players Stage

"Sadly, you can't TiVo Broadway shows...but there is another option — and it can be found in, of all places, Park Slope, Brooklyn...The Gallery Players have developed a reputation for reviving commercial hits...solidly entertaining." - The New York Times

"One of New York's secret treasures." - Rupert Holmes, Author of The Mystery of Edwin Drood

"It's worth going over the bridge to see the best of Off-Off-Broadway" - Jerry Stiller and Anne Meara

"Local Heroes" - Time Out New York